Home Audit Five Common Mistakes When Preparing for PCI DSS

Five Common Mistakes When Preparing for PCI DSS

Laptop, kartu pembayaran, digital padlock, dan checklist yang menggambarkan lima kesalahan persiapan PCI DSS

Written By

CBQA Global

Follow us:

PCI DSS preparation projects often experience delays and cost overruns, not because the technology is too complex, but because of poor decisions made at the beginning. Common issues include unclear scope, unnecessary data storage, and missing compliance evidence.

The good news is that organizations can prevent these mistakes by identifying them during the planning stage. Proper preparation helps reduce repeated work, control costs, and improve assessment readiness.

Below are five common mistakes we frequently encounter, along with their warning signs, business impact, and prevention strategies.

1. Incorrect PCI DSS Scoping

Warning Signs: The IT team claims that cardholder data exists in only one application. However, the organization cannot provide a verified cardholder data flow diagram. Supporting systems, such as server logs, backups, monitoring tools, and vendor access, are also overlooked.

Business Impact: The actual scope turns out to be broader than expected. During the assessment, assessors may identify systems that are not properly controlled. As a result, timelines are delayed and unexpected remediation costs arise. Conversely, an unnecessarily broad scope forces organizations to secure more systems than required.

Prevention: Map cardholder data flows from entry to exit. Include all connected systems and components that can affect CDE security. PCI DSS also requires organizations to document and confirm their scope at least once every 12 months and whenever significant changes occur.

Review the PCI SSC guidance on significant changes to the CDE. This helps make scope validation an ongoing activity rather than a task performed only before an assessment.

2. Storing Unnecessary Cardholder Data

Warning Signs: CVV codes, magnetic stripe data, or PINs are still stored in databases, application logs, spreadsheets, or customer support tickets. Full card numbers may also appear in emails and exported reports.

Business Impact: Sensitive authentication data must not be stored after authorization, even in encrypted form. Retaining such data can result in serious compliance findings. Furthermore, every unnecessary storage location increases the area that must be protected.

Prevention: Conduct data discovery across all systems. Remove data that is no longer required. Next, protect PAN that must be retained using appropriate methods, such as tokenization or encryption.

The principle is simple: storing less data reduces exposure to risk. Read the PCI SSC requirements for storing cardholder data for further guidance.

3. Untested Network Segmentation

Warning Signs: Network diagrams show separate zones. However, firewall rules are rarely reviewed, and no testing has been conducted to demonstrate that segmentation is effective.

Business Impact: Network segmentation only reduces PCI DSS scope when its effectiveness is demonstrated. Without supporting test evidence, organizations cannot rely on network separation to exclude systems from their PCI DSS scope. Consequently, security costs may increase.

Prevention: Test network segmentation through penetration testing. For merchants, segmentation controls must be tested at least every 12 months and whenever changes are made to segmentation controls or methods. Meanwhile, service providers are subject to testing at least every six months.

Test all segmentation controls in use. Also, ensure that the results are properly documented in accordance with applicable PCI DSS requirements.

4. Poorly Documented Compliance Evidence

Warning Signs: Security controls are already operating. However, when assessors request evidence, the team struggles to find it. Examples include missing or inconsistent access review logs, change tickets, scan results, and meeting minutes.

Business Impact: Controls without supporting evidence are difficult to demonstrate as effective. As a result, organizations may receive findings against requirements that have actually been implemented. Teams also waste valuable time collecting documentation at the last minute.

Prevention: Define the evidence required for each PCI DSS requirement from the beginning. Assign a clear owner and storage location for every document.

Examples of evidence that may be requested, depending on the assessment scope, include:

  • External vulnerability scan results from an Approved Scanning Vendor (ASV), where required.
  • User access review records.
  • Activity logs and security monitoring results.
  • Change management tickets.
  • Security testing and remediation documentation.

Organizations can also strengthen their IT governance and control practices by reading CBQA Global’s IT Audit article. The article discusses system evaluation, IT controls, and audit documentation.

Official guidance on SAQ processes and ASV scanning is also available through PCI SSC FAQ 1134.

5. Treating PCI DSS as an Annual Project

Warning Signs: The entire team becomes busy preparing for compliance only two months before the assessment. Afterward, security activities return to normal until the next assessment period.

Business Impact: Security controls can weaken between assessments. Consequently, new vulnerabilities and control gaps may go undetected. PCI DSS v4.0.1 emphasizes security controls as part of ongoing business-as-usual activities rather than annual preparation alone.

Prevention: Schedule vulnerability scans, access reviews, and log monitoring throughout the year. Assign clear control owners and establish regular reminders.

Maintaining compliance consistently is more efficient than rebuilding assessment readiness every year. Learn more about the updated requirements in PCI DSS v4.0.1: Securing Payment Card Data.

For additional information, read the official PCI SSC guidance on PCI DSS v4.0.1.

Conclusion

The Chain Reaction That Is Often Overlooked

Scoping mistakes can affect every stage of a PCI DSS project. An inaccurate scope leads to an unreliable gap assessment, unrealistic remediation budgets, and incomplete compliance evidence.

Correcting these mistakes during planning is generally faster and less expensive than discovering them during an assessment. Therefore, an early scope review is one of the most valuable steps in any PCI DSS project.

Quick Check: How Ready Is Your Organization?

Answer the following five questions. Every “No” or “Not Sure” response indicates an area that should be reviewed before committing the budget.

  • Does your organization have an updated and approved cardholder data flow diagram?
  • Can you confirm that no sensitive authentication data is stored after authorization?
  • Has your network segmentation been tested and properly documented?
  • Does every compliance evidence item have a clearly assigned owner and storage location?
  • Are security controls monitored and maintained throughout the year?

The more questions your organization cannot confidently answer, the greater the need to review its PCI DSS readiness before the assessment.

Read More from CBQA Global

Explore these related articles to gain further insights into payment security and IT governance:

  1. PCI DSS v4.0.1: Securing Payment Card Data
  2. PJP Audit: Securing Digital Payment Systems
  3. What Is an IT Audit and How Does It Protect Business Data?

Discover more industry insights and business updates through the CBQA Global News and Articles page.

Need PCI DSS Services for Your Business?

Preparing for PCI DSS requires a clear understanding of the requirements, accurate scope definition, control evaluation, and proper documentation.

Supported by a team of certified and experienced auditors, CBQA Global provides a communicative, improvement-focused audit approach. Our reports use clear language to help your team understand findings and determine effective corrective actions.

Contact CBQA Global to discuss your organization’s PCI DSS audit and assessment requirements.

WhatsApp: 0811 8468 777
Phone: +62 21 2781 4200
Email: [email protected]

Explore CBQA Global’s PCI DSS services:

PCI DSS Attestation Services

CBQA Global | We Inspire in Trust
Certification | Audit | Training | Sustainability

More CBQA Global News

Ready to Strengthen Compliance, Trust, and Business Resilience?

Get expert support for your ISO certification and compliance needs through structured services in Certification, Audit, Training, Verification, Validation, Sustainability, and Professional Training to strengthen governance, reduce risk, and improve performance.

Apply for This Opportunity

Name
Drag & Drop Files, Choose Files to Upload